Could you rate these levels?

[MKSLAYER]

theres one inside and one outside the zip has 2 jpg's in it thanks
[edit]just for the record please state which one your rating[/edit]

[someweirdperson]

That's actually pretty good.. A little plain, but it's fine.. 8.5/10
Mighty fine job.

[tlf288]

Those were good 2-3 years ago, but the are very below todays highly set level standards.

[PrinceDark]

grrrr!!!!!!!
It would be nice if you posted screenshots. I'm too lazy to open those up.

[Kaiser2]

Those are jpg files, not nw files, so Iguess they are screenshots...

[MKSLAYER]

yeah they would be im not very good with grass tiles which is not a good sign

[Spark910]

Not bad, although they are too big, you have made them too big so you feel you have to fill it all and so the detail gets spread out ant it looses its quality. Try them smaller and fill the rest of the level black.

[GoZelda]

Inside

Originality Rating:
I've seen this loads of times, only the curtains thing is new,
3/10

Detail Rating:
No, NOT detailed. Just look at the water... Further it's, nice.
4/10

Tile Rate:
Now, that's quite nice. Even due the grass tiles look, weird, it's nice. But even that could have some more detail.
6/10

NPC's/Light Effects
Well, the lights effects are nice. Nice, but nothing special. Same with chairs and couches.
6.5/10

Overall Rating:
19.5/40

4.5/10

Could get a bit more detail, just add more stuff and it will be nice. Leave the NPC's and stuff, they're, nice.

Outside Level:

Originality Rating:
This is quite common, a grass level with a podium. Nothing we haven't seen.
2/10

Detail Rating:
Not enough detail on the grass, and the water is waaaay to straight.
6/10

Tile Rating:
I don't like the trees, they're all the same place etc., trees don't do like that. The path is good, but unoriginal, except how it goes with the benches. The podium is a bit weird.
7/10

Light Effects:
Well, nice light effects, but familiar.
6.5/10

21/40

5.1/10

[MKSLAYER]

if it helps any the lights are the kind that zoom in and zoom out but not to much just around a .5 tile difference

[Devil]

Eh, I didn't really like them that much, but keep up the good work and you'll get better

[GoZelda]

Originally posted by MKSLAYER
if it helps any the lights are the kind that zoom in and zoom out but not to much just around a .5 tile difference

no it doesn't really helps.

[GoZelda]

Originally posted by Kaiser2
Those are jpg files, not nw files, so Iguess they are screenshots...

I think Princedark ment that he had to download the zipfile, unzip it etc. With "screenshots" people here mean that we just have to click on the link for a pop-up window with the level screenshot.