Review of Halloween Pumpkin Carving Contest

[Imperialistic]

[MattKan]

Is there a place where we can actually view the winners?

[Luca]

Originally Posted by Absolut_Crono

The situation was a lot worse than how Luda explained it. Regardless, it just doesn't make sense to me that second place would get 2 hats while first place got one, regardless of the spectrum from which hats are chosen. Before we could come to an agreement, it became more of "let me bombard you with personal attacks till I get what I want" than a real discussion. The biggest issue I have, is that the players all entered the contest knowing full well if they win the broom it is practically like winning nothing at all. My suggestion would be either to sell your current broom for a profit (if possible), or take the EP value of the Broom you won. 2 of the Halloween hats are worth more than the 1 broom, as is the hat ticket so those options aren't available.

As far as the voting goes, that was handled awfully. By the time I had known the voting began it was over already. From what I understand, Luca was the one who handled the specific voting. Regardless, I am not here to point fingers. Future contests will be outlined in much greater detail from the start to finish than this was, including periods from which you can vote (lasting at LEAST 2 days to be reasonable), Specific prizes like Door had (no "Or other things" that was added in there after Nike sent the post), etc.

On a side note @Luda, I don't know what those "other things" Luca promised were, but there is a possibility you can choose from that list of items when I find out what they are. If you would like the EP Value of the broom (Roughly 200ep) that would be fine as well.

Nike and Streety (with some help from Jazz on scripting, I believe) handled voting. I logged in during the last few minutes and cast my votes, and as far as I knew, voting had been up for the majority of that day. The only other involvement in voting I had was the donation of my own broom which, consequently, vanished since it wasn't given out.

I did add the "and possibly other prizes" or such on the end of Nike's prize list as a means of saying prize winners may get different prizes if they either didn't want or already had the specific prize they earned. Regardless, had I known prize distribution went this sourly, I would have stepped in and fixed it. As I heard nothing negative about the prizes from either players or staff, I assumed everything went fine. Apparently it did not.

Angryface.

[SwimChao]

Nike and Streety (with some help from Jazz on scripting, I believe) handled voting.

Do not even put that removed on me. I was not involved with that competition at all, in anyway shape or form.