The 4th Official Graalian Artist's Challenge: Finals !!

[LordZen]

Really sorry I'm behind schedule on this one. haha, that computer in CA, is the same one I used to play graal 4-5 years ago.

A:

B:

C:

D:

We will give it the usual 7 days I suppose.

---

Contest Update:

*sigh* I had to remove one of the entries, Goboom I will need to speak with you.

[Gambet]

Entry A was really well done. I like the theme and i think it was the best colorized out of all of them.


Woohoo for Entry A!

Im just wondering, why do you just put, for example, Entry A, EntrY B, etc. Just by looking at the other thread everyone can tell who made what piece. I think you shouldve had everyone email their work to you, or send via aim or something, that way the voting wont be bias, and would be fair. Just a thought.

.

[Scott]

A .

[Goboom]

I was just joking about the virus ZEN, my virus scanner dosent recognize it as a virus.
Well, good luck to all entrants.

[GoZelda]

I voted for D, but now I see how many people voted for that I had rather voted for B

[Crono]

you dont vote for things that other people vote for, gozelda, you simply vote for which you think is best. Not by author or what the majority thinks.

[GoZelda]

Originally Posted by Gerami

you dont vote for things that other people vote for, gozelda, you simply vote for which you think is best. Not by author or what the majority thinks.

I didn't knew for which to choose, I liked them both. Eventually I did like 'ineminemoooo' and picked D, but seeing as how little B has I'd rather chosen that one.

[protagonist]

A is excellent.

[xxCloudxx]

I voted for A <3

[LordZen]

Originally Posted by Gambet

Entry A was really well done. I like the theme and i think it was the best colorized out of all of them.


Woohoo for Entry A!

Im just wondering, why do you just put, for example, Entry A, EntrY B, etc. Just by looking at the other thread everyone can tell who made what piece. I think you shouldve had everyone email their work to you, or send via aim or something, that way the voting wont be bias, and would be fair. Just a thought.

.

This was considered in an earlier contest, and I decided that this is way is best.

People enjoy talking about their work, posting WIPs, and also I wont put every single entry into the finals, so emailing it to me would mean some people would never get to show off what they made.

Also, trying to hide who made what to that extent seemed sort of silly considering that the authors could easily just "tell" people which one they made, or show it to people in AIM or whatever.

Just as long as there isnt a blaring reminder right next to the picture when it comes down to voting time seemed well enough for me. A good compromise.

---

Goboom, ok, chill, lol. <3

[alarid0]

....
wheres mine....?


>=( im not voting

[Galdor]

haha it was to good to be on here. sorry al >.>

[davidpsy]

Wtf? Where is Alarids entry?! THIS IS RACISM I SAY, RACISM!

[Goboom]

Sexism...

[Galdor]

ya indeed

[Nappa]

I voted B, because it was alot sexier then the rest. I don't know who made which either.

[Snakeandy7]

E i say o_O

[LordZen]

Alarid, you didnt submit it on time. You know that. Sorry. :'(

BTW, everybody will have to re-vote. Sorry, there was no way around it.

[Darlene159]

A got my vote

[GoZelda]

Originally Posted by LordZen

BTW, everybody will have to re-vote. Sorry, there was no way around it.

Eh why?

[LordZen]

Had to remove an option..

[Myomoto]

A is cool, I really love the line art

[Galdor]

i voted b. why was gobooms removed?

[Myomoto]

He already had a submission so I suppose he requested it?

[Goboom]

Hmm, I wonder why mine was removed, Zen if you dont see me on AIM PM me or EMAIL me.

[alarid0]

crap i thought i at least posted the line art before the colored...
i guess not tho...
come on tho within 1 hour is it really THAT nessesary to stay strict till death to it

[Crono1508]

It was a hard choice for me between A, B, and D.
But at last, I voted B.
Great work halo41, you get my vote.

[Goboom]

It has been brought to my attention that my entry was deleted because it was almost identical to a drawing that can be found here. My entry seemed to be almost too close to it.

I agree with this opinion, but I honestly did not trace that image, I traced an image that I sketched and scanned into the comptuer that was based on a picture that I saw hanging up advertising a halloween dance in our school.

I am sorry and appologize for any confusion this has cost.
I am willing to accept responsiblity for any punishment seen fit if any is taken.

Again I am very sorry for any confusion that this has cost.
I am asking that you do not go off topic relating to this, this was not ment to be a discussion, only an explanation.

-GOBOOM

[alarid0]

but then...isnt it just that the source of both images (one on elfwood and yours) are the same? if you both drew basing from the same pic of nightmare before christmas...then is there really a big problem there

[Goboom]

Originally Posted by alarid0

but then...isnt it just that the source of both images (one on elfwood and yours) are the same? if you both drew basing from the same pic of nightmare before christmas...then is there really a big problem there

I guess so because stuff is close and it is hard to go by word when you dont truley know the person.

[Nappa]

Go Option B. Vote B Now Or Suffer The Wrath Of 1000 Suns.

[teshy2]

A all the way <3

d--(^__^)--b

[LordZen]

Galdor is the winner, lol, should have unstickied this already.