[TonyRivers]

problems:

ugly tiles, we will delve further into why your tileset looks like a steaming pile of garbage:

tile problem # 1: style- not a major factor but the style of the tile looks as if more that one person is working on it. If so I reccomend you start over again and have one person do the whole thing.

tile problem # 2: colors- maybe the most outstanding flaw in the screenshots in the that none of your colors go good together and are not easy on the eyes. I suggest you make up a general color scheme and stick with it.

tile problem #3: outlines: im sorry but those don't look like buildings to me (at all) I can harldy make out what is going on in the screen shots the only tiles I that arent eyesores are the ground and grass clump tiles. I cant really help you here I would just say use your mind when you create a tileset and think about perspective and basic shape.which brings us to problem numero dos:

which is the gun sprite which is way to large and dosnt resemble a gun very much. This server seems to be lacking in the graphics department so we will move on to a more complex problem:

Problem#3: theme and game play- first as this has already been stated there are 2 other western servers which all most likely basicly spawned from delphs western server a while ago. That means you have to compete with two other servers that have basicly the exact same concept and slightly better content. From what I have interpeted the server will be based around killing people and bounty hunters and sherrifs and gun fights which is basicly era a few decades back. A server has to be more complex than that.

In conclusion I don't have my hopes up for this server and don't see it becoming a phenomon since the sort who would play it already have era plus its competition with the other western servers.


hope this isnt too depresing for you but the truth hurts..