Quote:
Originally posted by Spark910
We don't really need a full discussion on every ban
|
Then it is illegal because it is unnecessary? Are you sure you don't want to rethink that a little?
Quote:
|
its some what a private issue
|
Evidently the banned member doesn't desire it to be private. And if the mods have something to hide then they're not doing their jobs properly.
Quote:
|
im sure most users can see the ban reason, so little grounds for discussion
|
And yet people still find issues to discuss. For example, the fairness of bans is often questionable, and clarification of the rules could realistically lead to greater general understanding. Again you seem to be reasoning that it's okay to outlaw these discussions because you consider them unnecessary - that the perceived absence of a downside justifies an action. If there is an
actual reason behind this rule then state it. If there isn't then repeal it.
In my opinion, this is a case of moderators acting on knee-jerk reactions rather than taking time to think about the pros and cons.