I think the main problems are how to prove that someone did something criminal (what if a bunch of people come and say "account XY killed one of us, we all saw it, jail him"? How to prove that? Okay, it may be in the log, so popos would need access to it...) and how it should be punished - a day in jail for one kill, two days for 2 kills? And what about scamming? I don't know what the log actually logs, but I doubt there can be solid proof that someine stole something from someone... maybe he even gave it then started to shout "robbery!". Also, what if I was jailed for a day, log off, come back tomorrow - no learning effect.
Oh, and what about people scamming and pking off tag?
I hope you see what I mean... I try not to read my post again, cause I won't
