[ReaperJ]

well first off all i never said you shouldnt stil have to get the ingreediants, i think you should not be able to cheat and get the list of ingreediants at a web site, i paid for a few scrolls and i dont think its fair that others can just look them up on the web

You should have to have the scroll in your posession at one time or another to make anything out of the ingreediants. Weather or not someone gave it to you or just let you read it, you should have to have it at one point in time.

It is not role playing to go on the information forum and read the alchemy recipies.