first one looks pretty good to me, 6/10. i would have given it probably an 8 but there's a tile error on those bottom trees, and i dont like those waterfalls at the top. They just sort of come out of nowhere. Also, i think you're grass detail seems a bit too ordered and patterned. Try and make it more spread out and use the weed/grass tiles to make clumps of joined areas.
As for the second, i think it looks great, except the way the grass is higher on the left and lower on the right makes it look wierd, because one assumes the water levels would be fairly similiar. o.O
either way, I give it 7/10. Good work
