Thanks everybody for your feedback. I'll put it to use in my server as it continues to develop.
So here's what I got from you.
You want a server that has...
+ A clear quest path
+ A guided learning curve
+ Something to do in every place
+ Everything fully tested
+ Fun core gameplay
+ An intuitive interface
+ A story that gives you a sense of purpose
+ A story you can relate to
+ Positive community atmosphere (that's you guys)
+ A good amount of content
+ Quality map construction
+ Fun multiplayer events
+ Unlockable hats, weapons, etc.
Even better would be if it had...
+ An original concept
+ Attractive graphics
+ Consistent presentation
+ Music that sounds good & compliments the game
+ Meaningful quests
+ Frequent updates
And you'd also like to see...
+ A wide selection of bodies, heads, & accessories
+ Original GANIs
+ A player-driven economy
+ Sexyhot weapons
+ Lots of hidden extras (easter eggs)
Sounds like a server I'd want to play on too
Nurica is now done with the concept phase and is now on to design. Thanks for the support.