View Single Post
  #21  
Old 03-02-2007, 05:24 PM
Kittah Kittah is offline
One Stoned Kittah
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Japan
Posts: 143
Kittah is on a distinguished road
People like this? The idea is great sure, but it's not pulled off wonderfully at all overall. There are bits of it that're great but I think the cliffwork needs some serious work, the water needs to have consistency in its layout (the waterfall on the left for example, with the cliffs suddenly diving inwards doesn't look at all convincing to me - bad attempt at fixing bad tiles). The detail, too is plain to my tastes. As always the graveyard tiles are terrible so I wouldn't have even considered using them.

Basically the idea and theme is great but the execution looks like a bad jumble of attempts at creativity. Probably just because I prefer a predominantly simple Classic style...
Reply With Quote