Which logo?
 

Which logo is better for Graalaxy, a futuristic playerworld in development.

1)
http://r.je/graalaxy.png

2)
http://r.je/graalaxy4.png


comments and suggestions are welcome.

I really like the top one :)

Top, for sure.

The bottom, but that's because I'm a rebel.
For actual artistic appeal, the top.

Top <3

top

The top is a bit more befitting to the title.

Graalaxy. Haha.

The top.

Neither, using the same font for every character is nastacular. AIM me and I'll give you a hand.

As opposted to using a different font for each character? That would look strange. Maybe making the G larger than the rest of the letters would be better, but other than that, i think it has to be the same font. Maybe i'm misunderstanding what you mean.

I must have no taste at all, heh. I told him i liked the bottom better. :)

Seems likely.

The bottom one has this real Halo 'feel', or Half-life2, one or the two. I dunno.

There was no Aztek or w/e in HL2 for sure lol so you must be talkin about that sub par game Halo.

Likely referring to the block-font combined with the circular design. :whatever:

The back round is extremely similar to the pattern on the Halo structure in both games.

I'm wondering why you have this repeated circular image. The repetition causes it to become the dominant visual element, which isn't good since it draws the eye away from what is important; the text.

In the first logo these circles are simply distracting, causing a clash of hierarchies. In the second, the circles are dominant.

Perhaps just have the circle around the G?

;)