Maloria V3: Mine tileset
 

This is for Maloria V3.. Thoughts?
other versions..:

final version
http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/6760/leveljb8.png

Looks out of place. I don't like it very much.

Agreed. It just looks...cartoonish oO

hot.
i like it.

sorry, i hate it, but i dont really like malorias tileset to begin with, its very clashy and dosent seem to conform to any style, Im still pretty convinced mals tileset is stolen, but without proof it's moot. hopefully mals gameplay will be better than their visuals for thier sake.

The more I look at it...the more I don't really like it :x
Just something about it irks me...

And our visuals are plenty nice...I don't know what you are talking about.

Not bad, i think its got loads of potential if you keep working on it.

Also, the maloria v3 tileset is ugly as hell, i said it from the start ¬_¬

I dont like this at all.

Yeah...well some of it I like...I kinda wish we would use the v2 tileset mixed with some of the nicer v3 tileset.

maybe add some fat boards to hold it up like they have in mines? =)

well it's updated, but i think i agree with smirt. It looks to busy i think..
http://img204.imageshack.us/img204/5187/levelud4.png

Keep in mind that this is only the walls he that he made so far.

the walls look -ok-, but try making a square room real quick...

some tiles just look better straight others curvy.

O.k., But sorry you guys went from making that nice lil hot key idea to this?
Jesus I'm sorry but this is just horrible.

Do the rocks in those walls not look flat to you? Cause they look horrible flat to me. And wasup I didn't know caves he walls had rocks that were perfectly lined up at the top and bottom.

I Personally think you effed up when you created the line art so you might as well start over.

But lets remember now people this is my opinion

Two separate graphics people here. I didn't even know he was working on a tileset.

Yeah I think you should start over with a new design, these tiles are really bad.

Thanks for that captain obvious. Oh yah, I forgot to mention it, but did you know that you're an ass hole ? Just letting you know.

I agree

You sound like Elk. If you can't take the criticism, then don't post asking for it.


I got straight to the point, without any wishy washy bullcrap that should make you feel like these tiles were good. I'm not the only person that thought of it, since I was agreeing to a previous comment that you should start over with a new design.


You're good with other types of GFX, not tilesets, at least from what I've seen from this mine tileset and the other dungeon tileset.


If it was "obvious" to you that you should make a new design, then you would have never posted the tileset for critique in the first place.

Criticism is defined as : disapproval expressed by pointing out faults or shortcomings;


I see disapproval, and not much else.. ?

Denotative definitions are weak in arguments, it's conatitive definitions and how you go about expressing such that make one strong.


It takes no analysis to state a denotative definition of a word.


What I stated was very much criticism, and also a means to improve by suggesting that you start over. I never once said that you should just give up, I was being encouraging by saying that you should start over.