My jack o' lantern gfx
 

Here it is :) http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b2...lantern-by.png

Cute :)

Hmmm rate it 1/10

Oh, 5/10 - the shape isn't very good. The shading isn't very good, and the color is a little too bright

roflmao plenty people say it owns i have had many people say its 9.5/10 are u blind? it pefectly shaded? it looks good in dark with a light... roflmao your blind worst complient ever gotten

Oh? Here's one I did.

I didn't know it was shaded until he said so

Thats to big...

Hahahaha.

changeimgzoom index,.1;

there smaller lol

Looks like pillow shading, if you zoom around 1000% or so. The inside kindof strays from pillow shading, but the outside definitely follows pillow shading though.

Haha. I love it when people can't take critisism. Nice job Stephen. :) I like yours.

Simply magnificent!

They must be stupid. The image itself needs everything Stephen said it needs.

I thought he was being sarcastic at first. Then I realized he wasn't. Your the one that asked for him to rate it, he was being generous with a 5/10

i go with a 3/10

Blah, that thing is ugly.
I am in school and got bored, so I re-colored it, no change to the lineart though.

Next time, have a pattern to your shade instead of a lot of randomness, don't follow the pillowshading pattern, and don't be afraid to go nuts with your colors.

http://img86.imageshack.us/img86/1661/pumpkins0aj.png
I did two versions, one that is dithered and one not. Your old one is in the middle, mine I believe is an improvement, nothing spectacular though.

As I mentioned previously, the shape of it isn't very good, and the perspective doesn't suit Graal o:

I Love Your Pumpkin Stephen!!!