Forum Smile(s)
 

I got bored one day. So I re-designed the forum smilys. Well one of them atleast. If they will be put to use on the forums, I will do the whole set and more, but if not, this is all your getting. :P
http://www.drunkenkangaroo.com/Forum_Smile.gif

Hrmm I prefer both of them.. :)
I like them both to be honest, it's hard to tell which to keep..

Nice idea. I would like to see new smiles too.

I like it, but i think your should choose a darker color for the eyes and mouth ;O

So I lied...
http://www.drunkenkangaroo.com/Forum_Smile-RollEyes.gif

Wow I love that one :D

I prefer the old ones. Gives the forums that nostalgic feel. :)

Nice job though.

We should just get and design totally new ones and get someone to add them :D

I made a whole set.. But they are too big for forums http://www.phosphyr.com/five/up/smileXD.gif

XD only looks good as a text emoticon. No matter how graphical smilies of it are made, they always look weird. :(:(

I like the shading on that, though. Not insanely overdone, and just kept basic enough to look good.

They look good, but I suggest darker lines for the mouth and eyes etc.

They look nice but

1) As said, use darker colors for the eyes and mouth

2) XD will always look messed up as a smiley or when it's right side up. (also as said :P)