Graal Forums - Shaded Legends (LAT Contest)

Graal Forums (https://forums.graalonline.com/forums/index.php)

- Level Design (https://forums.graalonline.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=6)

- - Shaded Legends (LAT Contest) (https://forums.graalonline.com/forums/showthread.php?t=134266207)

Shaded Legends (LAT Contest)

It might have been a better idea to hold a tileset contest first.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ffcmike (Post 1691547)

It might have been a better idea to hold a tileset contest first.

I might even get one person if I tried that. :O
It would kind of suck that they would be the first ones losing though..

Anyway, they are all working on type1 as well as beta testing it. :]
So far it seems to be alright, I have just updated it so it should be much easier, have cliff tiles, as well as a few other added things.

Some were decent, this next one they will review a tutorial and try to create an outside like Shaded Legends. ^.^;

This thread confuses me.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ducati_Link (Post 1691563)

This thread confuses me.

This should keep you updated:
http://www.graalians.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4849

This is for the Shaded Legends "So you think you can LAT?" contest.
20 contestants, 6 winners.
No experience, gold, or offline editor needed.

I will teach them and the ones who are the fastest learners and best personalities shall win. They will have the chance to become LAT should
they want to also.

They had four days to test it out. :D
10 days to make a level,
20 days to make a final level.

So far there are 15-16 contestants.

So are the levels posted.. yours? or theirs?

No offense, but all those levels are pretty poor =\. #3 is the only one that is semi good. Just passing on my feedback

Quote:

Originally Posted by ffcmike (Post 1691547)

It might have been a better idea to hold a tileset contest first.

Exactly what I was thinking.

As the contest states, no experience required, and it was in the testing phase.
You all shouldn't expect much from people first starting and testing a levels editor...

Here are the results of Assignment 1.

Sadly I'm not very organized so I don't have names :/.. Late newcomers, old people kicked... some switched around... Sorry.

Room - 02 : Askew was hired as a LAT. : Well done.
Could Fix: Redundancy in tables, one rock if picked up would show a tile error, fence pieces could be layered in the future.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...t/47b9af55.png

Room - 04 : Not bad.
Could Fix: Missing corner pieces, chairs look odd around the table but uses nice perspective which is a plus. Once again could use layers for the top part of the pole fence thing, and I need to redo the corner house piece.

Could use more details to the ground.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...t/68d0f1a4.png

Room - 05 : Good job.
Could Fix: I forgot to clear my block. D: The level looks alright, however the bushes through the grass ridges don't look that great. Almost as if saying the ridges aren't making the ground go up or down.. Can't really fix it but to redo the bushes not over many ridges. The house is kind of funky too... Other than that the level looks decent. I've used transitions like this in the past, however sometimes it doesn't look great, layers should fix it. (The road and grass) Also, some bushes can be hit and show errors.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...t/1e259e2c.png

Room - 06 : Not too bad.
Could Fix: A 2x2 dirt hole type tiles are creating a tile error in a grass corner, and the roof looks slightly plain... Also, some rock shadow looks kind of odd and would be weird if picked up. I've helped tell you about one bush line, but the other two were left with black edges. Could do a little better for the ground details but you did alright. Also, the roads are too small on the bottom, and look too natural.. but the place looks like a mansion so could possibly be as such.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...t/cdf68517.png

Room - 07 : Alright
Could Fix: The house looks semi alright, the top is slightly too far up front, and some of the walls are using wall ends which I've mentioned in the past.
This level looks too symmetrical and has tile errors / missing grass corner pieces. More details and ridging could be added. The entrance is just weird though...

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...t/afc16d6d.png

Room - 10 : Alright
This level is definitely unique... However, it is also full of tile errors, and some not even because I believe you have the wrong tileset. Need to work on the ground details like ridging and details in general, but overall the creativity is good.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...t/8ef2fca7.png

Room - 15 : ._o
Could Fix: Well.. It did look like someone did actually try and start something... Yeah...

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...t/8d21bc00.png

Room - 20 : Good start.
Could Fix: Well.. can't say too much.. there really are no details but the bushes are missing the correct corner tiles. I also like that you are using a small tilesheet in the top left. I think the roads are too ... perfect? and not that natural in a rural area. Not sure why there are chests on the roof.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...t/38549f2c.png

Some of these houses were way too big.

Should there be a final assignment or should this be it? I feel like for this being the first assignment some of you have learned a lot so far.

The next assignment will be quest like.

The 1st one is certainly the best out of the lot.

That was why he was hired straight off. ^.^; Still needs a little practice, but I think he is pretty good.

i love number 2

hire fireen his level looks decent

I don't think Fireenn started to actually join the server, I just let him have a level lol...

I am sorry, but they all look truly horrible to me..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sp_lit (Post 1694287)

I am sorry, but they all look truly horrible to me..

Would you mind explaining why per room/person for the two phases?

that is retarted not even good quality levels

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rave_J (Post 1694340)

that is retarted not even good quality levels

Would you mind explaining why per room/person for the two phases as well?

the level quality just a poor job no creative went to this its like u slap a 15 mins level together idk not enough detail or creative or unquie for me

In concern to the LAT Contest, lets just say it was a failure.
Due to, once again, my poor judgement in time, and outside reasons, like
the OLE being broken, lack of organization from my part, and lack of communication from my part... The LAT Contest died, this time around.

Pros:
One person was hired.
The tileset was fixed up slightly.
I know how I can improve the contest programs.
Many people wanted to try it.
This can be used as a server event, best level in 24 hours.
I know I need to fix up the OLE with a function like this easier...
Possibly accessed outside of the actual weapon script.

Cons:
No one really 'finished' and I feel like I've failed the inspired people wanting to do the contest. Eventually they lost interest and stopped coming on. Some of those who did not lose interest couldn't work due to the OLE being ruined.

For the future:
I may as well make the levels work as links. I've been having problems with the boxes... that can be fixed easily, but links would be less laggy...

Have the contest only last a month. Organize it and have instructions already planned out. Keep names and emails together as well as room numbers.

Anyway, I'm sorry I've let many of the contestants down,
I can only blame myself for the results.

Hopefully next time will go better.

P.S.:
Also, for some strange reason in the last month,
I've had three people apply for the contest that
started three-four months ago...

I'm not sure how they are being directed to his. :X

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rave_J (Post 1694388)

the level quality just a poor job no creative went to this its like u slap a 15 mins level together idk not enough detail or creative or unquie for me

But you understand that people without any experience were able to join and do the contest right? I think some turned out alright... Needed work, but alright.